Postgres Tells You Your Query Was Slow. Not Which Index Was Wasted.

TL;DR: Postgres has pg_stat_user_indexes . It tells you how many times each index was scanned. It does not tell you whether the slow query you're chasing actually used the index you added for it, or whether you're maintaining indexes the planner never picks. I built a 3-file analyzer — a query wrapper, a logs table, a dashboard — and the first time I ran it against my own production database, 20 of my 51 indexes had never been scanned. 78% of my total index disk was being maintained for nothing.